Excellent lengthening mascara I've been using this mascara, always in the same tube, for several months and it's only now starting to run out. I've always used the excellent Pupa Vamp, but I wanted to try this cheaper one and I really liked it. I have thin lashes, not very dark and medium length but not very curled, and I hate using an eyelash curler. With this mascara, my lashes become black, a little thicker, and much longer. It's easy to use on the upper lashes. I sometimes use it underneath, too, and with a little care, it works well. It lasts all day. It's not waterproof, and I have no problem removing it with makeup remover. Used with a lash primer, it works even better!